Skip to content

Faith in Florida: Doubles Fundraising Through Event-Based Asks and Relational Donor Engagement

At a Glance

  • Organization: Faith in Florida
  • What was tested: Whether event-based asks, relational outreach, and messaging that shows donors what their gifts support could build individual and monthly giving to fill a gap left by lost grant funding.
  • Investment: A $35,000 grant from Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC), plus monthly coaching and strategic assistance from Progressive Multiplier (PM).
  • Grant Period: August 2024 - August 2025
  • Central result: Fundraising revenue rose 129%, from $37,899.57 in FY2024 to $86,928.80 in FY2025. The turning point was replacing direct asks with gratitude-first conversations.

The Organization

Faith in Florida is a multicultural, nonpartisan network of congregation-based community organizations across Florida. Its mission is to build a "Beloved Community" by developing grassroots leaders in over 35 counties, empowering working-class neighborhoods to confront local issues such as gun violence, voter suppression, mass incarceration, the housing crisis, systemic racism, and youth concerns. Through civic engagement, coalition-building, and community organizing, Faith in Florida works to address the systemic racial and economic inequities that perpetuate poverty — and to ensure that every eligible Floridian has a voice in their democracy.

The Starting PointOur movement is rooted in community, where we lift each other up & make sure everyone has the to

In early 2025, Faith in Florida lost a multi-year grant and faced an unexpected $500,000 gap. It launched a monthly giving program, DOCE ("donate once, commit every month," at $12 a month), with a goal of 4,000 sustainers. It had 17 monthly donors giving just under $25 a month on average. An organization that had downsized at the end of the prior year now needed new revenue.

The original plan tested two ideas: whether charging for events or asking for donations raised more, and whether telling people what their gifts support beat general appeals. The larger goal was an annual campaign of $1.2 million from 100,000 donors. Success meant converting one-time givers into steady monthly supporters.

What Happened

  • February–April: events and staff. A national Black History training drew 46 paying attendees and raised $4,857.92 against $2,500 in expenses. Slides on DOCE with QR codes led six new donors to sign up. A March email and social appeal lifted DOCE to 19 donors. An April all-staff training introduced the campaign, and DOCE reached 21 donors.
  • May: a sharper focus. Individual donor coordinator Mia Morrison began leading outreach, and PM and Faith in Florida narrowed the work to converting donors to monthly sustainers. An honest clergy call about the challenges nonprofits face raised $27,255.95 as supporters shared stories of Souls to the Polls, emergency response, and youth employment. At Pastor Rhonda Thomas's suggestion, a staff peer-to-peer competition with personal giving links launched. Together with Doce, it brought in $63,486 from 402 donors that month.
  • June–August: the decision that mattered. Mia's phone banking at first brought weak response. Coaching from PM changed three things:
    • She researched each donor's past giving in a spreadsheet.
    • She opened with thanks for a specific gift and what it accomplished, then invited a $12 monthly gift while welcoming one-time gifts.
    • She acknowledged hard times before making any ask.
  • Results followed: 49 donors and $5,151.65 in June, 59 donors and $1,608.63 in July, and 29 donors and $5,834 in August.

What Changed

  • Revenue. Fundraising grew 129% year over year. DOCE grew from 17 donors and $415.86 in February to 21 donors and $502 in April. Two Black History calls in June raised only $52 combined, so results were uneven.
  • Organizational capacity. Faith in Florida now has a donor-history spreadsheet, tested call scripts, individual giving links for staff, and a thank-you letter for every donor, even a $2 gift. A donor impact flyer is planned once a communications hire is in place.
  • Early signs of mission impact. Executive Director Rhonda Thomas began receiving unsolicited calls praising Mia's warmth and clarity. One caller said, "That fundraiser of yours is a real powerhouse." The organization’s current goals are expanding to more counties and rebuilding capacity lost to downsizing.

What We Learned

"Instead of making it Faith in Florida's work, it's our work and you are a part of us." — Mia Morrison

  1. Gratitude before the ask works. After Mia started researching donors and thanking them first, she reported "a lot more call backs and a lot more answers" as well as more money raised. PM called it the "co-conspiracy method," and said the response shows a message that moves people to act. Implication: Spend preparation time on who the donor is and what their gift did.
  2. Relationships drive giving more than a platform does. Mia named "core relationships and belief in the mission" as the two pillars. The staff competition worked through personal links to friends and family. Some donors gave six times without ever becoming monthly donors. Implication: Track total giving, not just sustainer sign-ups.
  3. Monthly conversion remains the open question. Donors asked why they should give monthly instead of once, and DOCE reached only the low twenties against a 4,000-sustainer goal. The registration-fee question was not settled either. Implication: The monthly case needs clearer framing and more testing.

The Multiplier Effect—and What Comes Next

Faith in Florida's fundraising story is not only about the $86,928.80 raised. It is about what that money, and the habits behind it, can keep producing. The sections below separate what is documented today from what the organization expects and hopes for.

How the gains compound

The strategies built during this coaching relationship are designed to grow in value each time they are used.

  • Every donor becomes a relationship. Mia's donor-history spreadsheet tracks each person's total giving, with some donors dating back to 2020. Each call, thank-you letter, and follow-up adds to that record, so the next conversation starts warmer than the last. Every donor now receives a thank-you letter, even a $2 giver. The team is weighing email against hard copy by donor and gift size, because a roughly $0.60 mailing on a $2 gift could make a donor question how money is spent.
  • Every contact can reach others. After a call, Mia sends an email and text with a QR code and link and asks supporters to share them with family and friends. Staff giving links already showed their power in the May competition. PM observed that each unsolicited caller praising Mia likely represents 10 to 30 others who feel the same way. These are the early signs of a widening circle of goodwill.
  • Every event becomes a place to invite ongoing support. The team learned that the monthly-giving ask works better when it comes early. When it was moved earlier in the July virtual Black History training, that event raised $444.51, "a significant increase" over earlier events. In August, a training on Emmett Till moved naturally into funding conversations. Testimonies on the May clergy call prompted new pledges. Each gathering can now do mission work and relationship-building at once.
  • Each skill learned stays with the team. Mia credits PM’s coaching with sharper preparation, research, and communication. She now asks what data a meeting needs before she walks in. Executive Director Rhonda Thomas noted that Mia joined Faith in Florida's youth department at age 15, a reminder that fundraising capacity is growing from within the organization's own leadership pipeline.

The reframing from "Faith in Florida's work" to "our work" may be the most durable multiplier. Donors who feel like family give more than once, and they bring others with them.

What the team plans next

The next steps Faith in Florida shared are practical.

  1. Convert one-time donors to monthly sustainers. This starts with the main donors the $100K campaign surfaced through staff and clergy relationships. The team plans to highlight those donors and invite them to give monthly. The case for monthly giving needs a clearer answer to donors who ask why they should give monthly instead of once.
  2. Keep the $100K campaign going. Organizers will keep reaching people they personally know, applying the gratitude-first lessons.
  3. Plan beyond this year. A senior-team meeting in Miami reviewed philanthropic donors aligned with the mission and planned work for the rest of this year and next. Mia expects FY2026 revenue to be much bigger than FY2025's. At one point she said she expected it to "skyrocket," though no specific target has been set.
  4. Build impact materials. After a communications hire, donors will receive a flyer or deck showing where their gifts went.
  5. Strengthen the team. Early in the engagement, Faith in Florida identified a need to train both board and staff on moving from passive to active fundraising. That remains a natural area for continued support, although no board development plan has been finalized.

Mia is also willing to share what the team has built. She will provide her scripts and the structure of her donor spreadsheet, with donor information removed, and speak with other organizations. She suggests that future partners meet earlier and keep a shared document of scripts, flyers, and donor approaches.

The long-term vision: sustaining the work

The grant was meant to help Faith in Florida develop independent revenue. When a multi-year grant ended, the organization faced a $500,000 hole. Its answer was to widen the base of people who care, since reliance on any single funder had proved fragile. Individual giving spreads that risk across hundreds of people. The team's phrase for monthly giving, "not a project but a lifestyle," names the aspiration: predictable income that supports planning and budgeting, and a backbone of support outside unpredictable funding sources.

That vision is early. DOCE stands at 21 donors against a goal of 4,000, and the $1.2 million, 100,000-donor campaign is still ahead. What exists now is a tested way of talking to supporters, a growing record of who they are, a thank-you practice, and a staff more comfortable asking. Faith in Florida also invested its own funds in the effort, supplementing Mia's salary and covering her travel.

For PM and other organizations, the lesson is that a grant paired with coaching can change how a team talks to supporters, and that those changes compound. Faith in Florida's next test is whether those conversations turn into steady monthly income, and whether that income helps it rebuild and reach more of the communities it was founded to serve.

WE ARE NOT GOING BACK!When we vote, we help shape the future of our families, neighborhoods, and